51 replies to this topic

[glennbo]

I think Marcus has a good point

[Bananas]

As mentioned, it would be a good option to be able to edit/correct/update/delete our own reviews particularly to reflect changes in course conditions and facilities over time.

[admin]

Bananas - Thx for the feedback. The problem with that is of course wayward idiots deleting all their reviews for whatever reason. Reviews have dates that reflect the time they are written. If your view changes you just need to right another review with your updated views. Reviews serve as timeline of what people's views of the course over time. Anyone reading can see a course might have been drought stricken in 2004-2005, reviewers start saying it improved in 2006, more reviews in 2007 saying renovations have helped the course etc etc. If you could change an old review then you lose all that timeline of information. We could certainly allow editing within a week of posting it to fix typos etc but that would be about it. I can't think if any site that allows you to change your reviews.

[Bananas]

Thanks for the insight admin - makes sense.

[divot1372662237]

A couple of times I've gone to put new reviews in and the courses haven't been listed. The only one that springs to mind right now is the Kings Cove Golf Club in Metung, Vic. What's the best way to request courses to be put into the database? Link

[divot1372662237]

bump

[Smergen]

Good Bump Divot. I'd just like to throw my support behind the Course review section. Really makes a difference when searching for a new course to play. And I hate it when the last review was pre-2005 (granted some of the goat tracks I go to may not have been attended by ISGers since then!) as I know they aren't really relevant to current conditions. So i encourage all to chuck a review up of any course you've played recently. Trust me, people do read them!

[divot1372662237]

Bump. It's been nearly a year and that King's Cove Metung course is still not listed. It is worth listing.

[Pipp]

WTH??? I saw emoticons in some posts on this thread????

[Francie]

Admin...............can you please advise how some of the courses have pictures of the courses on their review page and some don't? Some also have a lead in comment beside the picture. Is there some way I can get a picture for my home course displayed? (which I recently did a review for) Also can a I get a brief comment displayed beside the picture? (perhaps from our web page)

[Tullyg]

You have to try Port Fairy in the wind. A true links course and a true challenge.

[Francie]

You have to try Port Fairy in the wind. A true links course and a true challenge.

 

Yep........... done that, just recently.    Warrnambool's also pretty tough with rain, wind and never having played it before, also.  

[CaNadiAn MiCk]

Admin...............can you please advise how some of the courses have pictures of the courses on their review page and some don't? Some also have a lead in comment beside the picture. Is there some way I can get a picture for my home course displayed? (which I recently did a review for) Also can a I get a brief comment displayed beside the picture? (perhaps from our web page)

Francine  did this post ever get answered?  Before my time;)

[Tullyg]

Yep........... done that, just recently.    Warrnambool's also pretty tough with rain, wind and never having played it before, also.  

Congrats on the Shipwreck Coast Classic win. That's a great tournament.

[Francie]

Congrats on the Shipwreck Coast Classic win. That's a great tournament.

 

Thanks Tullyg........I was very surprised the afternoon players couldn't match my 36 points.