Why is it that Judd gets all the praise when Black consistenly is the leading ball winner in all games….

I agree that Black is another level above Judd, however what about the youngster, “Pendlebury” ????

Pendlewho!!!!!!!!!

That young Superstar in the Black and White !!!

judd is miles better than black. not to say black isn’t a star also, but judd is not surrounded by the strong talent that black is

Judd spent most of his career surrounded by Cousins and Kerr, only this year has he been the lone star, that said Gibbs, Murphy and also Stevens are not bad support.

Sorry only just saw this topic.
Both players are freakishly talented but play a completely different game.
Black is a consistant work horse who does his job week in week out. What he does best is get the ball out of contested situations and deliver it with amazing accuracy and does it consistantly.

Judd however has an amazing ability to read play which gives him the ability to receive the ball at speed and uses his agility and kicking skills to move the ball into attack quicker than anyone.

I prefer Black as I think he makes more of a contribution to the team but watching Judd break a game open with sheer speed is something to watch. This I think is why he is ranted about more often (the flair factor).

judd is far better. because he plays for carlton!!!!!!!!!!!!!

i think if we put them in a cage fight to the death, then it would be very even, but judd would die first

chessman: i like that theory. perhaps we could do th same with ben cousins and matt orford. hopefully they would both lose….

Chessman, welcome back, haven’t seen you on here for a while.
Nice to see that the cage fights are still alive and kicking.
Black would wipe the floor with Judd. He can’t run fast so he would have learn’t to stand his ground through High School.

i’ve been busy working. Once the fine weather is back i’ll work less and get some golf in and tryto organise a few isg cage fights.
Wazza vs ???