Loose impediment

ForumsRules of Golf | 9 posts
 

A large tree, separated from its trunk, has fallen on the course. No local rule has yet been applied. If a ball come to rest close to this loose impediment impeding a player’s stance or area of swing, does the player have any other options given that the tree cannot be moved?

 

If you can’t move it, you’re out of luck. Play the ball as it lies, as it’s not an obstruction.

As long as you don’t delay play, you could take your Husky or Farm Boss out of your bag and chop it up.

 

Publish now you sound like racinfarmer, lol

 

this happened in the Pro Am at Queanbeyan last year, a big branch fell off a gum that guards the end of the dogleg 18th, if you shoot too long the ball ended up smack in the middle of the branch. Cost a few boys a shot or two that day I can tell you….

Cliff Manley

ahhh "consistency" the holy grail of golf....

 

D.23/7
Fallen Tree
Q. Is a fallen tree a loose impediment?
A. If it is still attached to the stump, no; if it is not attached to the stump, yes.

D.25/9.5 Tree Falls onto Fairway During Stipulated Round

Q. A large tree falls onto a fairway during a stipulated round and cannot readily be removed. What should the Committee do?

A. The most appropriate course of action will depend on the circumstances in each case. The Committee has the following options:

(1) require play to continue, providing no additional relief from the fallen tree;
(2) suspend play and have the tree removed;
(3) declare the tree and the area covered by the tree to be ground under repair (Rule 25-1) and may, as an additional option, establish a Dropping Zone; or
(4) in equity (Rule 1-4), adopt the relief procedures under the Local Rule for Temporary Obstructions, thus providing intervention relief from the fallen tree. (Revised)

D. 23-1/4
Q. If part of a large branch which has fallen from a tree (and thus is a loose impediment) interferes with a player’s swing, may the player break off the interfering part rather than move the whole branch?
A. Yes

 

I wonder what the ruling bodies would think of a player having his caddy swinging down and holding a branch out of the players line of flight
The branch attached to a much bigger branch or tree thats fallen and is a loose impediment

I cant see any reason why not , but it would sure get some people talking

 

My guess is the Ruling Bodies would think that the player should be given a 2 stroke penalty for having physical assistance when he makes a stroke.
(Rule 14-2, “Assistance”)

Or he could be improving his line of play, and the 2 stroke penalty should be given to him according to Rule 13-2 “Improving Lie, Area of Intended Stance or Swing, or Line of Play”

 

13-2 I’d overlook
You make a good point re 14-2 …..maybe under 1-4 he might get lucky

But 1 thing is for sure , the caddy would have to be wrong in the head to attempt such a thing lol

 

Publish now you sound like racinfarmer, lol


For racinfarmer, the tree wouldn’t need to be dead.

ForumsRules of Golf